Ta-Nehisi Coates

« Free Agency and the Myths it Creates | Main | Portrait of a Recession »

Emily Dickinson #67

03 Jul 2009 08:50 pm

{Dwayne Betts}

Success is counted sweetest
By those who ne'er succeed.
To comprehend a nectar
Requires sorest need.

Not one of all the purple Host
Who took the Flag today
Can tell the definition
So clear of Victory

As he defeated - dying -
On whose forbidden ear
The distant strains of triumph
Burst agonized and clear!


TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://ta-nehisicoates.theatlantic.com/mt-42/mt-tb.cgi/11147

Comments (7)

Vance Maverick

I like how she applies "forbidden" to the dying soldier's ear (because the triumph he hears through it is forbidden to him), and "agonized" to the strains of triumph (whether because he hears them through agony, or because they cost an agony to those who are actaully earning them).

Do you know the date on this? In particular, had the Civil War actually begun? This doesn't seem to depend on more than an abstract understanding of war (not a knock, of course).

J.W. Hamner

There is no poet I despise more than Emily Dickinson. She is the Anti-Poet. A giant hack mixed with a heavy does of anachronism. I can't believe anyone could read that nonsense and not want to stab themselves. Repeatedly. What is the draw? I don't get it.

4th of July Med-
Itation

Freestyle Vino

COMPOSITION!

my 2 cents of being

IN RELATION

WITH A UNIVERSE


OF COLOR

BURST OF BLOSSOM MAN-MADE THINGS AS WELL POW!

EASY PEASY
PARA VIVIR

Adoration
Convocation
Variation
Striation
JAZZ

No. 1
It’s LEMONADE

(the whole thing should be centered but hard to get the effects here, Happy 4th)

Bruins2Lakers

jW
I used to feel similarly and it annoyed me when I asked my American lit students to flip through the 8 lb. textbook and choose a poem that their group could analyze for the class and they always chose her poems because they were short, ignoring far richer stuff--Langston Hughes, Countee Cullen, Julia Alvarez, et al. Then, amazingly, they had trouble with these short little gems like "Hope is a Thing with Feathers" or "Because I Could Not Stop for Death." So together we'd deconstruct each line, each word usage--and a funny thing happened: There was a whole lotta something behind what appeared to be a whole mess of nothing.
Her poems are like those homes that from the front facade look small, but the lot behind it runs deep. Remember this woman shunned fame, feared critics, and kept it all in a shoebox for years until it was discovered posthumously.
She's not my favorite, but when you take it apart and reassemble she's got the messages on point in few words. Kind of like Hemingway, who I never got either, but I liked his succinctness even if I'd rather read the wordy Faulkner.
You know who you NEED to have here is Wanda Coleman. Ever read Aptitude test? I've seen people just about fall out of their chairs. Same with Charles Bukowski, although he also has penned some very tame poems, as well. Like this one:
____________________________________________________________________

The meek have inherited

if I suffer at this
typewriter
think hoe I'd feel
among the lettuce-
pickers of Salinas?


I think of the men
I've known in
factories
with no way to
get out--
choking while living
choking while laughing
at Bob Hope or Lucille
Ball while
2 or 3 children beat
tennis balls against
the walls.

some suicides are never
recorded.

Bruins2Lakers

how not hoe (LOL)

Post a comment

<-- /safecount -->